The Cherished Wife (Noelle and Charles) novel Chapter 152

Samiel knew Winter's true colors all too well. She might act all proper when she was out, but at home, she was a different person. Her petty tricks might fool others, but they did not fool him.

"Domestic helpers are people too. They work hard for their money and deserve respect. You shouldn't be hitting people and breaking things. Where did you get such a temper?" Samuel tapped his cane on the floor before turning to Julian. "Look at the fine daughter you've raised."

"Dad!" Julian was taken aback. He never thought Winter would do such things, especially at home. He believed that despite her occasional spoiled behavior, she was still a well-mannered young lady who might complain a bit about Noelle but nothing more. "I'll make sure to teach her a lesson about this."

"Please teach her the right way," Samuel said, clearly not convinced. "I just don't understand how you've raised her. She's been overly competitive since she was little, always taking things from Noelle. Snatching a toy is one thing, but growing up to steal Noelle's boyfriend? Is this the wonderful daughter you've brought up? And now, she's even hitting people and breaking things. She doesn't act like a proper young lady at all!"

Samuel continued to scold Winter. He had thought that since the incident was long past and Noelle had let it go, he might forgive Winter and Xavier. However, seeing Winter now, Samuel was completely let down.

"Dad..." Jade said, sounding upset with Samuel, "Winter is still young. Plus, she had a tough day outside. Shouldn't we, as her parents, show her some concern instead of blaming her? Won't that just make Winter feel worse?"

"Upset? She's a big star, and everyone adores her. You've all spoiled her," Samuel said. Looking at Jade's protective behavior, he shook his head, feeling a mix of helplessness and disappointment. "If Noelle were in trouble, would you stand up for her like this? Never mind, she's your child. You handle it."

With that, Samuel walked away, leaning on Eli for support. He did not notice the angry look in Winter's eyes as she hid her face in Jade's hug.

"What's wrong with doting on Winter? She's my daughter. If I don't treat her well, should I be kind to that—"

"Enough!" Julian cut Jade off sharply. "Stop talking nonsense! Since Winter's okay now, take her back to rest."

Jade wanted to argue, but she ended up closing her mouth without a word. Winter's eyes sparkled, though. She had picked up on something from Julian and Jade's exchange!

Was it about Noelle?