The Cherished Wife novel Chapter 138

Charles chuckled and shook his head. He gently patted Noelle's head. "Do you think she wouldn't hold a grudge against you if you didn't do this?"

Noelle sighed, reluctantly admitting the truth in Charles' words. Still, she decided to avoid Winter as much as possible in the future. "You don't understand. Winter doesn't let things go easily. She—"

Charles shook his head. "It seems like she bullied you often in the past, didn't she?"

Noelle gave a bitter smile. "I guess it's pretty obvious!"

Moreover, she would always end up on the losing side. To avoid direct confrontations with Winter, Noelle moved out early and only returned for family gatherings to see her grandfather, Samuel.

Charles' deep eyes settled on Noelle, and he could tell from her resigned expression that she had often been at a disadvantage with Winter over the years. "She's quite something."

Noelle raised an eyebrow. "I didn't expect you to compliment her!" She noticed the shoes being packed by the sales attendant, and the manager had come over as well.

"Mr. Hoffman, these shoes..."

"Give them to me!" Charles frowned slightly, taking the shoes. "What about those flats from earlier?"

"They're right here!" The sales attendant had anticipated this and quickly handed over the flats. "Ms. Shaw, please change into them."

Noelle raised an eyebrow and glanced at Charles. He nodded. "Go ahead and change. It's better not to wear high heels when you go out."

He paused and then continued with a smile, "You can wear them at home."

"Alright," Charles replied, walking behind Noelle. He gave the sales attendant a meaningful glance.

The sales attendant quickly said, "Goodbye, Mr. Hoffman."

After Charles and Noelle left, the store manager approached the sales attendant, giving her an approving look. "You did well today."

"Thank you, sir!"

Wearing the flats made Noelle feel much lighter. She walked ahead, turning back to look at Charles, who was following closely behind. "Thank you very much for today!"

Noelle knew that if Charles had not intervened, she would have once again suffered at Winter's hands. Winter always assumed Noelle would not cause any major conflict. Plus, with Annie and Suzy supporting her today, Noelle would have been at a disadvantage no matter what.